DAILY DAWN
04, December 2005
Need for reinterpreting Islam
By Altaf Hussain (Founder & Leader MQM)
THE international geopolitical scene has changed radically since the 
cataclysm of 9/11. In the heyday of the Cold War, when the Soviet Union was the 
adversary for the West, the Islamic concept of Ijtihad had an entirely different 
connotation and perception in the minds of the Americans and the Europeans than 
is the case today.
The tragedy of 7/7, perpetrated right in the heart of London, has further 
radicalized the western perception of Islam and the Muslims.
What reigns supreme today on the minds of the West is a highly distorted and 
convoluted image of Islam. A religion of peace and tranquillity that Islam 
inherently is in its pristine sense is, regrettably, associated with violence, 
bloodletting and terrorism, Islam, today, is stuck in the western mind as a 
religion which has ‘zero tolerance’ for other religions and their followers.
We all know that this is not what Islam stands for. However, it is also a fact 
that the ill-informed, fanatical and, in a sense, opportunistic religious 
orthodoxy — the so-called clerics and mullahs — have only fuelled this erroneous 
perception of Islam in the western minds because of their ill-advised 
exhortations and sermons that do no service to Islam. The erstwhile Taliban 
regime in Afghanistan, for instance, did enormous damage to the name of Islam in 
the western world and made the Muslims a laughing stock throughout the world.
Enlightened and well-informed Muslims — in a clear majority in the Muslim ummah 
— are, indeed, conscious of the fact that these radical and extremist clerics 
don’t represent them and don’t speak for them. The majority of the Muslims in 
the world consist of moderate, law-abiding and pacifist people who neither 
believe in preaching a gospel of hatred against any other religion, nor do they 
subscribe to a distorted philosophy of jihad.
I believe that I speak for every sensible, enlightened and moderate Muslim in 
the world when I declare that the Islamic spirit of accommodation for others is 
ignited by the Quranic teaching of Lakum deen-o-kum, wallya deen, which 
translates as your religion is yours and my religion is mine.
Another universally applauded verse of the Holy Quran categorically lays down 
that there is no compulsion, or force, in Islam; the Quranic injunction says: La 
Ikraha fid Deen.
I would, therefore, like to appeal to my fellow countrymen, women, students, 
teachers and others to use all possible and peaceful means at their disposal to 
rectify and set right the wilfully propagated, and erroneous, perception in the 
western mind that Islam and violence are synonymous.
The early history of Islam as a message of hope and redemption is replete with 
glorious examples of Islam enriching the world with its mission of peace. The 
first temporal period of Islamic rule, the Khilafat-e-Rashida (the Enlightened 
Caliphate), that spanned three decades after the demise of Prophet Mohammad (PBUH), 
was the finest example of governance guided by peace and tolerance for all, 
Muslims or non-Muslims.
Although khilafat as an institution fell on bad days after the murder of the 
last enlightened caliph, Hazrat Ali, the basic Islamic norm of tolerance and 
peaceful coexistence with others and among the Muslims themselves continued to 
hold sway. The learned Imams — spiritual guides and religion’s interpreters — 
whose teachings are still regarded as beacons of light by Muslims all over the 
world — never wavered from a course of moderation and tolerance. Scholars and 
guides, such as Imam Malik, Imam Shafai, Imam Abu Hanifa, Imam Ahmed bin Hanbal 
and Imam Jafer Sadiq, may have differed in their interpretation and exegesis of 
Islam but never issued a fatwa against others. Today, mullahs and two-bit 
scholars among the Muslim ummah feel free to declare their opponents kafirs 
(non-believers) and don’t shy away from preaching intolerance and violence in 
the name of Islam.
Let it be known to all that Islam doesn’t teach its followers to remain cut off 
from, or non-communicative with, the followers of other religions such as 
Hindus, Buddhists, Christians, Jews and others. The Holy Prophet Mohammad (PBUH) 
interacted actively with believers of other religions and didn’t mind entering 
into contractual commitments and agreements with them.
It was ironic that in an age as advanced and enlightened as the 21st century the 
world was witness to an obscurantist and regressive Muslim regime like the 
Taliban, who violated the Islamic values of non-violence and tolerance. They 
were so archaic and backward in their views as to declare radio, television and 
other modern means of communication as unIslamic; they also made a mockery of 
Islam by forcibly excluding women from the mainstream of life and denying them 
the fruit of education. What else were the Taliban if not belonging to the long 
gone Stone Age?
What our younger generation of Muslims, students in particular, ought to 
remember is that in this age when non-Muslims are keeping a hawk’s vigil on the 
words and deeds of us Muslims, there is an unavoidable need for us to be 
realistic in our vision of Islam and pragmatic in its application to our 
everyday life.
I believe that we must correlate our action to measure up to the requirements of 
our age and adopt a realistic and pragmatic code of life that takes into account 
the following facts:
a. thought process and thinking changes with the passage of time; b. moral and 
civic values change too with a new lifestyle and dress code; c. technology 
dictates its own changes, introduces new inventions in sciences, communications 
medicine, pharmacy etc. d. sexual mores and traits change and usher in values 
that may have been taboo before; e. old myths die, or are radically transformed 
beyond recognition, and are replaced by values that may eventually become myths 
themselves.
There is an ineluctable compulsion on us, especially in this age when Muslims 
are being subjected to microscopic inspection by the non-Muslim world, to 
establish our values transparently and leave no confusion about them.
For instance, we have to let the world know clearly and categorically that Islam 
is not at war with the world, or with modern technology and inventions; and that 
we are an enlightened and progressive people who can coexist happily and 
comfortably with other peoples, irrespective of their beliefs or religious 
dogmas.
We must get rid of our weakness to get fixated on ideas and concepts proven 
wrong with the passage of time. Islam’s universalist ideology is what we must 
preach to ourselves and the world. We have done great injustice to ourselves and 
to the Poet of the East, Allama Iqbal, by narrowly projecting him as only an 
architect of Pakistan, instead of highlighting his message of universalism that 
he so rightly articulated in his famous poem, Sarey Jehan Se Accha Hindustan 
Hamara.
A qualitative change in our thought process should induce a new era of Ijtihad 
among the Muslims of the world. We don’t dispute the importance of the excellent 
commentaries and exegeses written by eminent Muslim scholars and interpreters. 
But what they dilated on were problems of their age, not necessarily ours too. 
There is, therefore, binding on us to interpret our religion in the light of the 
challenges posed to us by the 21st century and not remain mired in, for 
instance, the 17th century when the famous Fatawa-i-Alamgiri were compiled.
It is the crying need of the times that Muslims must take control of their lives 
by reinterpreting their religious values and mores in the light of their own 
age. Islam is a dynamic force that can’t, and shouldn’t, be held hostage to any 
one time frame or period. We must come to terms with our times and prove to the 
world that we are a progressive people who can move with the times and advance 
rapidly to take our due place among the most enlightened. This alone would 
ensure a place of honour for Muslims in the universal community of mankind.
The writer is the founder and leader of the MQM.